#crabcakecrawl 2012, Part 2

by JenniferA - Bread and Putter on August 14, 2012

On Saturday, after a breakfast of homemade baked oatmeal a la Wendi, it was on to downtown Baltimore and Lexington Market. It’s an indoor market with stalls selling everything from fresh produce to VHS tapes (yes, really!) We wound our way through both ends of the market until we arrived at Faidley’s, which in and of itself is a market selling everything from raw oysters to fresh muskrat (yes, really!)

Instagram Photo

But our main goal of course was lunch, and Faidley’s is serving up traditional-style crab cake realness, as in they’ve been around since the 1880’s and may have invented traditional style.

Instagram Photo

And holy moly, Faidley’s did not disappoint.  Look at the size of that thing! 

Instagram Photo

This was easily my favorite crab cake so far – perfectly seasoned, super fresh tasting crab, and it was huge! My advice if you find yourself at Faidley’s is to just skip the sides all together and maybe get two gigantic crab cakes, or maybe hit the raw bar before or after a singular crab cake because the sides just weren’t all that.  The cucumber salad was tasty at first but just tasted like too many pickles after awhile and the macaroni and cheese was gummy and seemed to have a distinct lack of cheese.  Wendi’s husband (The Mistah) tried the creamy crab soup and was disappointed.  It had a gluey texture and a distinct lack of crab.  But this is all unimportant!  We are talking crab cakes here and if you want an amazing, gigantic, real-deal Baltimore style crab cake, Faidley’s is the place to be.

Torrential rain thwarted our plans to take our Faidley’s to go and have a picnic at Fort McHenry so I didn’t get to do much Baltimore sightseeing, but more crab cakes awaited us that evening.  I had been tweeting, facebooking and instagramming all this crab cake goodness all weekend and at this point got a comment on one of my posts – aren’t you sick of crab cakes yet?  Hell no!

The final stop of the crawl was at Gertrude’s at the Baltimore Museum of Art. Gertrude’s is the restaurant of famed Baltimore chef John Shields and it is a beautiful, soothing space.

Instagram Photo

I think I’d like to live here.  Specifically, here, in the museum, in the restaurant and on that terrace.  Ahhhhhhhh!

Instagram Photo

I started with the Maryland crab soup.

Instagram Photo

What? Yes, more crab!  If you are what you eat, I am a crab by now.  Hey, kid, get offa my lawn!!! Get it? I’m a crab so I am crabby!  Haaaaaaaa! Okay, I’ll stop now.

It was lovely – a sort of minestrone style vegetable base, but not overly seasoned so you can really taste the crab.

Instagram Photo

And here is my entrée – I went with the traditional style crab cake, served along with mashed potatoes and sautéed spinach.  And it was another winner – the flavor reminded me of Faidley’s but with a little more of a kick.  Beth also ordered the traditional and didn’t care for hers as much, so I am wondering if hers was an unfortunate fluke.  Wendi, The Mistah and Beth’s husband Noel all had the special crab cake of the day which was the most unusual we encountered as it appeared to be breaded and deep fried or pan fried.

Instagram Photo

Finally, there was dessert.  I bravely tried a funky sorbet – honeydew, cucumber and cayenne.  It was delicious at first with lots of refreshing cucumber flavor, but the more I ate the more the cayenne overpowered and I couldn’t finish the whole thing.  I might have to try making some plain honeydew cucumber sorbet at home.  The crispy edible bowl it was served in was tasty too.

And so, #crabcakecrawl came to end.  I had a blast.  Check out Beth’s #crabcakecrawl post here to see us all looking kind of crabby.  And, a quick shout-out to Colleen who was supposed to join us but a family emergency kept her home.  We missed you, Colleen!  In the end my favorite crab cake was Faidley’s, but this may require more taste testing.  I like Beth’s idea to continue the crawl and bracket the results.  It would be a tough job eating all those crab cakes but we are just the women to do it!  Thank you again to Beth, Noel, Eileen, Adryon and especially Wendi and The Mistah for making #crabcakecrawl happen!

Did you like this? Share it:


#crabcakecrawl 2012, Part 1

August 8, 2012

Once upon a time, I had this wonderful revelation. I was traveling for work in Virginia with a boss who no longer works for the same company but who knew where the best food was to be found in every city we visited.  He was also really good at rounding up the troops and getting […]


Just a lil’ ole steakhouse

Thumbnail image for Just a lil’ ole steakhouse June 13, 2012

So, what could be interesting enough to drag me out of blog-hiding and make me want to post before I burst? Well, I have a restaurant recommendation for you, but only if you happen to find yourself in Wynne, Arkansas. Then again, if you find yourself in Wynne, Arkansas, chances are you already know about […]


Fiddleheads – a PSA

Thumbnail image for Fiddleheads – a PSA May 10, 2012

These are fiddleheads, one of those delicious yet fleeting spring treats.  I picked some up at my local grocery store this weekend and I was so excited!  There were only a few packages, and it didn’t say anything about where they came from.  But still, fiddleheads!  Wheee! I’ve cooked fiddleheads before.  Not often, since they […]


Asparagus Gratin

Thumbnail image for Asparagus Gratin May 3, 2012

For once, my blog slackerliness is totally going to work in your favor!  This is another recipe I made on Easter, but I had to make it with non-local asparagus.  Now, asparagus season is here in New England and you are now armed and ready with this worthy preparation. Looks can be deceiving.  This dish […]



Thumbnail image for Faves April 30, 2012

My sister has another one of her photo hunt challenges going on and this one is nice and easy – Favorites.  Which isn’t to say this slacker got right on top of it and dutifully took all these photos with the assignment in mind. But, since I tend to take pictures of my favorite things […]


Vanilla Bean Sable Cookies

Thumbnail image for Vanilla Bean Sable Cookies April 17, 2012

This is another post about Easter but you should not in any way wait until next Easter to make these cookies.  Oh, hell no. You need to come up with any excuse to make them and pronto.  Arbor Day.  Earth Day. Mother’s Day. Flag Day.Memorial Day.  You Made It Through The Work Week Without Punching […]


Raspberry White Chocolate Tart

Thumbnail image for Raspberry White Chocolate Tart April 10, 2012

Did you have a nice weekend? Did you celebrate a spring holiday of your choice? I hosted Easter dinner once again and I decided to change a few things up on my regular menu, starting at the end with this pretty dessert. I usually make a carrot cake but for some reason I just wasn’t […]


Strawberry Meyer Lemon Tart

Thumbnail image for Strawberry Meyer Lemon Tart April 3, 2012

Quick!  Run to your local store and see if they still have any Meyer lemons. (Or if you are like my Twitter pal Sheri over at Pork Cracklins, just step out into your Silicon Valley neighborhood and grab a few off of a tree, any old time of year. Yes, I am jealous.)  I got […]


Wayback Wednesday – My Mother’s Granola

Thumbnail image for Wayback Wednesday – My Mother’s Granola March 21, 2012

So, I seem to have fallen out of the swing of blogging on any sort of regular basis. I thought maybe I’d get back into the swing of things with a Wayback Wednesday post. This one works particularly well because it is my mother’s recipe and her birthday is this month and I am seeing […]